How to Know If Your Commercial Leader Has Hit Their Ceiling

How to Know If Your Commercial Leader Has Hit Their Ceiling

Not every commercial leader fails outright.

Some meet their budget. The Board still likes them. But behind the scenes, something’s off.

• Growth has slowed
• The strategy feels reactive
• Marketing hasn’t evolved
• Execution is solid, but momentum has faded

In these cases, the leader may not be failing — but they’ve hit their ceiling.

Look for These Signs

1. They Repeat What Worked — Even If It Doesn’t Anymore
   They’re still using the same playbook from two years ago — even though the customer has changed, the market has moved, and the company has outgrown that phase.
2. They Can’t Lead Cross-Functionally
   They struggle to align with Product, Operations, Finance, Market Access, or the ELT. Conversations are tactical, not strategic. The team still executes — but there’s no unified vision.
3. They Focus on Short-Term Wins, Not Long-Term Structure
   They chase deals. They build urgency. But they’re not building the commercial infrastructure — comp plans, segmentation, enablement, or insights — that creates scalable, predictable growth.
4. They Hire in Their Own Image
   They bring in people they know, not necessarily people the business needs. This creates blind spots in capability, style, and diversity of thought.
5. They Struggle With the Board or Investors
   They speak in anecdotes, not numbers. They can’t clearly explain strategy or performance. This erodes credibility — even if no one says it out loud.

If you’re seeing signs like these, it may be time to revisit when to make a change.

Why CEOs May Struggle to Make the Call

Most CEOs have build strong relationships with their commercial leaders — and don’t want to replace them without clear failure.

But when you’re scaling, “fine” isn’t good enough.
You need someone who can:

• Build across functions
• Perfect scalable systems (e.g. CRM)
• Adapt to investor and/or Market demands
• Lead through ambiguity
• Recruit future-ready talent

That takes more than charisma or track record. It takes a different kind of leadership.

If you're ready to raise the bar, start by evaluating the traits of high-performing commercial leaders.

At Alder Brooks, we help CEOs and Investors assess whether their current team is still the right team — or whether it’s time for someone who can lead at the next level.

‍