How to Build a Success Profile Before You Hire

How to Build a Success Profile Before You Hire

Too many executive hires are made with good intentions — and bad process.

Companies lean too heavilon resumes, interviews, or referrals to make one of the most critical decisions in their business: hiring a Chief Commercial Officer, VP of Sales, or VP of Marketing.

It’s a big reason why so many executive searches fail — not because of a talent shortage, but because the process lacks structure.

But without a clear definition of what success looks like in your unique environment, even a “great hire” can fall short.

That’s where a Success Profile changes everything.

What Is a Success Profile?

A Success Profile is a structured framework that defines the traits, competencies, behaviors, and drivers needed to succeed in a specific leadership role — inside your company.

It helps you evaluate candidates objectively, instead of defaulting to the “best resume” or “strongest interview.”

Companies that use Success Profiles in executive search see:

✅ Better leadership performance
✅ Faster onboarding
✅ Higher team productivity
✅ Lower turnover in commercial roles

How to Build One in 5 Steps

1. Start With the Business Goals

What does success actually mean for this role?

You’re not just hiring a title — you're hiring someone to drive specific, measurable outcomes. Before you recruit, clarify what you need this leader to accomplish in the first 12–24 months.

That could include:

• Growing top-line revenue by a specific target
• Launching a new product or therapeutic area
• Entering a new customer segment like academic medical centers or IDNs
• Turning around an underperforming sales or marketing team
• Building a commercial function from the ground up

Start with the end in mind — then reverse-engineer the type of leader who can make it happen.
‍

2. Analyze What Works in Similar Companies

If you don’t have strong internal examples to work from, look outside your walls. The best Success Profiles are grounded in real success patterns — not wish lists.

Ask questions like:

• What traits or competencies show up repeatedly in top performers at similar-stage companies?
• What kind of Sales or Marketing leader has succeeded in a similar market — for example, in Diagnostics, Devices, Tools, or Therapeutics?
• Do they have experience selling into similar customers (health systems, hospitals, specialty clinics)?
• What style of leader worked in similar product categories or growth phases (early stage, scale-up, pre-commercial, etc.)?

You’re not copying — you’re studying what works, so you can apply it to your business with confidence.

‍

3. Define the Success Factors

This is the core of the Success Profile.
Break it down into:

✅ Traits — e.g., resilience, adaptability, executive presence, etc.
✅ Competencies — e.g., team building, sales strategy, market development, etc.
✅ Behaviors — e.g., collaboration, decision-making, urgency, etc.
✅ Drivers — e.g., growth mindset, impact motivation, competitive fuel, etc.

Bonus: Add examples. What does each of these look like in action?

4. Get CEO and Board Alignment

Before you launch the search, lock in alignment with your CEO or board.

Ask:
👉 What’s non-negotiable?
👉 What matters more — experience in a therapeutic area, or leadership in a scaling phase?
👉 What type of person fits the way your team works and communicates?

When everyone is aligned on what you’re hiring for, better decisions follow.

5. Use It to Guide the Entire Hiring Process

Once your Success Profile is complete, use it as a filter — not just for the final decision, but throughout the entire process.

It should guide:

• The job brief and position description
• Your interview questions and evaluation criteria
• How you benchmark candidates across interviews
• Internal alignment during candidate debriefs
• Final decision-making with your CEO, board, or investors

Instead of comparing resumes or personalities, you're now comparing every candidate to the same standard: a clear, structured definition of success inside your business.

Define Success First. Then Recruit.

A Success Profile won’t guarantee the perfect hire.

But it will significantly improve your odds of recruiting the right leader — someone who aligns with your business, your goals, and your team.

At Alder Brooks, we help Life Sciences companies use Success Profiles to bring structure and confidence to high-stakes hiring — especially for Sales and Marketing executives, where the risk of a mis-hire is highest.

Not sure if your current Sales or Marketing leader can scale with the business? Here's how to tell when it’s time to make a change.